Mobile Industry Review - Latest Comments in No talking please, we’re on a plane

Re: No talking please, we’re on a plane

Mike42 — Sun, 01 Jun 2008 19:06:03 -0000

Funnily enough, I'm not after light entertainment when commuting. It is one of the few times on my day when I get uninterrupted time to think, compose documents, emails etc. For many others I know it's the same. The background noise of the train and conversational chatter is something you can filter out, but a one-sided loud mobile conversation is distracting even with headphones on.

Indeed we all do use our mobiles when on public transport - but personally I only take calls if I know they are urgent, and then I limit it to an 'I'm on the train, I'll call soon' or 'yes honey, be home at 7' sort of thing. No reasonable fellow passenger minds tolerating that - it's a part of our lives now, and we all appreciate a bit of latitude in managing things. But to assume that you can treat an intimate public space (and if I can touch you, I call it intimate) as your own mobile office is absolutely not on.

We may have to agree to disagree on this one.

/m

Re: No talking please, we’re on a plane

AJ — Fri, 23 May 2008 13:44:47 -0000

Ah, come on. I have a theory on this. Everyone hates other people using mobiles on public transport but, from experience, they seem to feel any ban shouldn't apply to themselves.

Mike42, the gelled up salesman are the best. The comedy value is hard to beat sometimes.

Re: No talking please, we’re on a plane

Mike42 — Fri, 23 May 2008 06:11:01 -0000

AJ, you are the rarest of people, that enjoy listening to some braying yahoo or gangsta or gelled-up salesman when on public transport - especially long-haul like planes or trains, where many people choose to read, sleep or partake of other passtimes requiring concentration.

Most people see forcing others to listen to your prolonged conversation as the height of inconsideration and arrogance. I don't think many mind a quick 'yes...no...OK, I'll call you later' but when it stretches to many minutes of inane babble, business jargon, street slang or whatever, it just grates.

£0.02

/m

Re: No talking please, we’re on a plane

SteveRowlands — Fri, 23 May 2008 05:52:03 -0000

Ha, I don't imagine my hatred of such conversations..... It's lucky airlines use plastic knives and forks, or else I'd have started a stretch in chokey, picking up the soap for big uncle bob, years ago!

Re: No talking please, we’re on a plane

AJ — Thu, 22 May 2008 16:14:26 -0000

Why is everyone so against using a mobile on a plane. Anything to relieve the boredom. Night flights excluded, obviously. Also, I am usually slightly amused by other peoples' mobile phone conversations on public transport. It doesn't really bother me that much, it is such a feature of modern life. I think people imagine they get more annoyed about these things than is really the case.

Re: No talking please, we’re on a plane

ollysk2 — Thu, 22 May 2008 09:43:05 -0000

Man, I would HATE to have voice calls on the plane -- I hate even sitting next to that random person who somehow wants to tell me their life story over the course of 3 hours.

However, I'd love to be able to SMS/email/data/etc, so I'm right there with the majority on this one I guess.

As for the whole use of phones on planes, if you've got an N95 throw it into offline mode and then use it in landscape with the media keys exposed -- I've done this many times and don't get hassled for doing so (I think they just assume it's a PMP of some sort).

-olly

Re: No talking please, we’re on a plane

MartinSFP — Thu, 22 May 2008 07:47:38 -0000

Every plane I go on says you can't use your phone even in offline mode. Very irritating and means I have to take an iPod as well as a phone to entertain me during the flight.

Planes need internet access but there's no way people should be allowed to make voice calls.

Re: No talking please, we’re on a plane

David McQueen — Thu, 22 May 2008 06:02:04 -0000

I couldnt agree more. I dont mind being able to pick up SMS or even read up on some notes but I would not want voice calls on a plane. I can just about stomach them on trains and buses as it is.

Incidently I just found out that my Nokia E61 can go to offline mode when I am in a plane. Duh!

Re: No talking please, we’re on a plane

SteveRowlands — Thu, 22 May 2008 04:15:44 -0000

To be honest, there is nothing I am looking to forward to less than the introduction of mobiles on planes. Only in the 'voice' capacity though. Data/SMS etc is fine, as long as the phone is in silent.

Just imagine the awfulness of being sat next to a fat salesman, with 'wet-look' spikey hair, in his Tesco £19.99 suit, whilst howling down his phone to his 'accountant' to sell his 4 million Harrods shares, and transfer it to his 'Lamborghini' account......

We all know he is actually on the phone to his wife, trying to tell her to pay the gas bill, but trying to look 'successful'........